Whether Americanstationery doesn't fit your budget, lacks features you need, or you simply want to explore options — here are 10 office & equipment alternatives worth considering for your small business.

Quick Comparison

Store Rating Coupons Top Strengths
Americanstationery Current
— 5 View
Quill Quill
4.5/5 15 Ease of Ordering/Website Usability 8/10 Fast Delivery 9/10 View
Paper Source Paper Source
1.8/5 14 View
123inkjets
— 9 View
123 Refills
— 7 View
Checkoutstore.com
— 7 View
Michaels Michaels
1.9/5 7 View
Staples Staples
2.0/5 6 View
Shoplet Shoplet
2.5/5 6 View
Levenger Levenger
4.4/5 5 Product Quality 9/10 Customer Service 8/10 View
Office Depot Office Depot
1.8/5 5 View

Detailed Comparison

Quill

4.5/5 (331 reviews) 15 coupons

Quill.com is a popular online retailer for office supplies, praised for its user-friendly website and fast delivery. While most customers report positive experiences, some have encountered issues with order fulfillment and customer service.

Strengths

  • Easy-to-navigate and user-friendly website
  • Fast and reliable delivery service
  • Wide selection of products and readily available

Weaknesses

  • Order cancellations due to inventory issues
  • Inconsistent customer service responsiveness
  • Occasional issues with damaged or incorrect items
Ease of Ordering/Website Usability
8.5
Fast Delivery
9.0
Product Selection & Variety
8.0
Rewards Program & Savings
7.8
Customer Service Issues
4.0
Order Fulfillment Problems
4.5

Paper Source

1.8/5 (100 reviews) 14 coupons

Paper Source receives mixed reviews, with customers praising product quality and selection but frequently citing issues with customer service and order fulfillment. While some enjoy the unique stationery and gifts, many report negative experiences that impact their overall satisfaction.

Strengths

  • High-quality paper and printing
  • Unique and cute stationery items

Weaknesses

  • Poor customer service responsiveness and helpfulness
  • Frequent shipping delays and order errors
  • Difficulties with returns and refunds
Customer Service
2.0
Shipping & Order Fulfillment
3.0
Product Quality
8.5
Returns & Refunds
2.5
1

123inkjets

9 coupons
1

123 Refills

7 coupons
C

Checkoutstore.com

7 coupons

Michaels

1.9/5 (159 reviews) 7 coupons

Michaels receives mixed feedback, with many customers praising the variety of products and helpful in-store staff, while others report issues with online orders, shipping, and customer service. The inconsistent experiences make it crucial for small business owners to weigh the potential benefits against the reported drawbacks.

Strengths

  • Helpful and friendly staff in some locations
  • Wide selection of arts and crafts supplies
  • Convenient store locations

Weaknesses

  • Poor packaging leads to damaged items during shipping
  • Unresponsive or unhelpful customer service
  • Inaccurate online inventory information
Customer Service
4.0
Shipping and Delivery
3.5
Online Ordering Issues
4.5
In-Store Experience
7.0
Product Quality
6.0
Coupons and Discounts
6.5

Staples

2.0/5 (712 reviews) 6 coupons

Staples reviews highlight mixed customer experiences, with some customers praising the store's customer service and product offerings, while others report issues with order fulfillment and general store operations.

Strengths

  • Competitive bulk pricing for office supplies
  • Responsive and helpful customer service

Weaknesses

  • Unreliable order fulfillment and delivery
  • Inconsistent in-store service and operations
Order Fulfillment
6.0
In-Store Experience
5.5
Customer Service
7.5
Product Quality
8.0

Shoplet

2.5/5 (30 reviews) 6 coupons

Shoplet is an online retailer offering a wide range of office and medical supplies, but customer reviews reveal significant concerns about order fulfillment and customer service. While some customers praise Shoplet's prices and selection, many report issues with shipping, damaged goods, and unresponsive support.

Strengths

  • Competitive pricing and discounts
  • Wide selection of products
  • Easy ordering process

Weaknesses

  • Frequent shipping delays and non-delivery
  • Poor customer service and responsiveness
  • Inaccurate order fulfillment and missing items
Shipping & Delivery Issues
3.0
Customer Service Problems
3.5
Order Accuracy & Fulfillment
4.0
Pricing & Value
8.0
Website Experience
7.0
Returns & Refunds
3.0

Levenger

4.4/5 (867 reviews) 5 coupons

Levenger is a popular choice for stationery and office supplies, known for its high-quality products and excellent customer service. While some customers report occasional shipping delays and backorders, the company generally meets or exceeds expectations.

Strengths

  • High-quality and durable products
  • Excellent customer service
  • Wide variety of products

Weaknesses

  • Shipping delays and backorders
  • Occasional product defects
  • Website navigation issues
Product Quality
9.0
Customer Service
8.5
Shipping & Delivery
6.0
Pens and Ink
8.8
Circa System
8.0
Packaging
8.3

Office Depot

1.8/5 (712 reviews) 5 coupons

Office Depot receives mixed reviews, with many customers reporting negative experiences with online orders and customer service. While some praise in-store experiences and helpful employees, recurring issues with shipping, returns, and billing create frustration for many.

Strengths

  • Helpful and knowledgeable staff in some store locations
  • Efficient and friendly service from specific employees
  • Convenient in-store printing services

Weaknesses

  • Frequent shipping delays and delivery issues
  • Poor customer service experiences, including long wait times and unhelpful representatives
  • Difficulties with returns and refunds, especially for online orders
Shipping and Delivery Issues
3.0
Customer Service Problems
3.5
Returns and Refunds Difficulties
4.0
In-Store Experiences
8.0
Billing and Account Issues
2.5
Website and Online Ordering
4.5